Case study · Personal Injury · Orlando, FL

The cheapest leads signed zero cases.

How Michael T. Gibson, P.A. signed 19 personal injury cases in one month on $49K, and why we moved budget away from the channel with the lowest cost per lead.

MG
Michael T. Gibson, P.A. · Auto Justice Attorney
Orlando, FL · 17 years practicing · Client since March 2025
19
Signed cases in one month
$2,596
Cost per signed case
21.8%
Lead-to-signed rate
$49.3K
Ad spend · Meta, LSA, Google Ads
The law firm & the problem

17 years in practice. Three channels and one question: which signs cases?

Michael T. Gibson, P.A. has practiced personal injury law in Orlando for 17 years and had worked with more than 10 marketing vendors before choosing Lexvertikal.

We launched Google Ads and Google Local Services Ads together in March 2025, then added Meta. With three channels live, each reporting its own version of a conversion, the job was to find which spend produced signed clients, not which channel produced the cheapest form fill.

Practice area
Personal injury
Market
Orlando, FL
Client since
March 2025
Channels
Google Ads · LSA · Meta
Scoreboard
Cost per signed case
Where the signed cases came from

Google Ads took 11% of the budget and 0% of the cases.

Spend by channel against signed cases by channel, same month.

  • Meta Ads
  • Google LSA
  • Google Ads
Share of ad spend
Meta51.6%
LSA37.1%
Ads11.3%
Share of signed cases
Meta57.9% · 11
LSA42.1% · 8
Google Ads: 18 leads, 0 signed cases
Spend: Meta $25,450.93 · LSA $18,318.71 · Google Ads $5,559.01. Signed cases: 11 · 8 · 0. Single reporting month.
Cost per lead vs. cost per signed case

Cost per lead said Google. Signed cases said Meta.

Meta's leads cost three times more than Google Search leads. Meta also signed 41% of them. Measured per signed case, Meta and LSA landed within $25 of each other.

Cost per lead

Meta
$943
LSA
$436
Google Ads
$309

Lead-to-signed rate

Meta
40.7%
LSA
19.0%
Google Ads
0%

Cost per signed case

Meta
$2,314
LSA
$2,290
Google Ads
no signed cases

Ranked by cost per lead, Google Ads looked like the best channel. Ranked by signed cases, it was the only one that produced none.

Same month. Leads: Meta 27 · LSA 42 · Google Ads 18.
What we did

Track to the signed case. Then move the money.

01

Qualified the Meta form

Lead forms screened for accident-related inquiries before a lead ever reached the intake team.

02

Tracked to the signed case

Spend, leads and signed cases reconciled channel by channel. Not platform-reported conversions.

03

Moved the budget

Google Search was deprioritized and spend shifted to Meta, the channel producing the most signed cases.

The numbers

One month, channel by channel.

One month, channel by channel.
Channel Spend Leads Signed Lead → signed Cost per signed case
Meta Ads $25,450.93 27 11 40.7% $2,314
Google LSA $18,318.71 42 8 19.0% $2,290
Google Ads $5,559.01 18 0 0% —
Total $49,328.65 87 19 21.8% $2,596
  • Meta Ads

    Spend
    $25,450.93
    Leads
    27
    Signed
    11
    Lead → signed
    40.7%
    Cost per signed case
    $2,314
  • Google LSA

    Spend
    $18,318.71
    Leads
    42
    Signed
    8
    Lead → signed
    19.0%
    Cost per signed case
    $2,290
  • Google Ads

    Spend
    $5,559.01
    Leads
    18
    Signed
    0
    Lead → signed
    0%
    Cost per signed case
    —
  • Total

    Spend
    $49,328.65
    Leads
    87
    Signed
    19
    Lead → signed
    21.8%
    Cost per signed case
    $2,596
Another month, same system · April 2026

22 signed cases in April.

The same operating system at a different channel balance: LSA carried the month, with 17 of 22 signed cases.

22
Signed cases
184
Qualified leads
$51,324
Ad spend · LSA, Google Ads, Meta
17/22
Signed cases via LSA
In the client's words
"

In 17 years, I've worked with over 10 vendors in this space. This has by far been the best experience I've had. Every expectation I had has been met or exceeded.

MG
Michael T. Gibson
President & CEO, Michael T. Gibson, P.A. · Orlando, FL
Take the next step

Every channel looked fine on cost per lead. Only two of them signed cases.

30 minutes with the founder. We'll look at your last 90 days of spend, your case mix and your intake numbers, and tell you which of your channels is actually signing cases.

Book a 30-min strategy call →
No sales team · No SDR · Founder-led from intro to onboarding

Ready for more signed cases? Ready for better ROI? Ready to stop wasting ad spend? Ready to lower acquisition costs? Ready to scale your firm?

Free Strategy Call →